How to Negotiate a Pay Rise: Scripts and Timing That Actually Work

Slug: how-to-negotiate-a-pay-risePillar: Business and Finance > CareerKeyword: how to negotiate a pay riseTagline: The timing, data, and words that workExcerpt: Negotiating a pay rise feels uncomfortable — but most managers expect it. Here's exactly how to prepare, what to say, and when to ask for a salary increase.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

Why Most People Don't Ask (And Why They Should)

A 2024 LinkedIn survey found that 70% of professionals who asked for a raise received something — either the full amount or a partial increase. The ones who didn't ask got nothing. Fear of being seen as difficult or greedy keeps a lot of people underpaid for years, when their managers would have quietly said yes to a reasonable, well-prepared request.

So let's deal with that discomfort and turn it into a concrete plan.

The Research Phase: Do This Before You Say Anything

Walk into any salary conversation with data, not feelings. Check your market rate on at least three sources: Indeed Salaries, Glassdoor, and LinkedIn Salary Insights. You're looking for the median and the upper range for your exact role, in your specific city or region, with your years of experience.

At the same time, document what you've delivered in the past 12 months. Not a job description of your duties — actual results. Revenue generated, costs saved, projects completed early, new responsibilities you've taken on without a pay adjustment. Concrete numbers beat vague claims every time. "I managed the social channels" is weak. "I grew our Instagram following 40% and led the rebrand launch" is what gets you a raise.

When to Ask: Timing Matters More Than People Think

The best time to ask is shortly after a clear win — finishing a major project, landing a big client, or receiving positive feedback from senior leadership. Your impact is fresh and the company is in a positive frame around you.

Performance review cycles are the obvious choice, but don't wait if you've just had a standout moment. You can also ask proactively before a review — it gives your manager time to go in already thinking about it.

The worst times: when the company has just announced redundancies, when your manager is under pressure, or right after a piece of negative feedback. Read the room.

How to Start the Conversation

Don't ambush your manager. Send a brief message asking for a 30-minute meeting to discuss your compensation — give them time to prepare too. When you're in the room:

"Thanks for making time. Over the past 12 months I've [specific achievement 1] and [specific achievement 2], and I've taken on [new responsibility]. I've also researched the market rate for this role in [location], and the range is [X–Y]. I'd like to discuss moving my salary to [specific number]."

State a number. Not a range — a specific figure. Research consistently shows that anchoring with a specific number leads to better outcomes than deferring to whatever they want to offer. Aim for the top of your researched market range, not the midpoint — you can come down, you can't go up.

Experts generally suggest requesting a 10–20% increase if you're genuinely underpaid relative to market. For an annual increment in a fairly-paid role, 5–8% is typical.

Handling the "Not Right Now"

Sometimes you'll hear "the budget's tight" or "let's revisit in six months." That's fine — but get specific before you leave the room. Ask: "What would I need to demonstrate to make this happen?" and "Can we set a date to revisit?" A vague deferral becomes a concrete plan with two questions.

If the answer is genuinely no for the foreseeable future, that's also useful information. It tells you whether this role has a ceiling.

What Not to Do

Don't base your ask on personal expenses or financial need — "I need more because my rent went up" is the weakest possible argument. Your employer is paying for value delivered, not your cost of living.

And don't threaten to leave unless you genuinely mean it and have something to leave for. Empty ultimatums damage trust and often backfire.

For more career and finance guides, visit our Business and Finance hub and our Career section.

FAQ

How much of a pay rise should I ask for?

If underpaid relative to market, 10–20% is a reasonable ask. For an annual increment in a fairly-paid role, 5–8% is typical. Always anchor to market data, not a random percentage.

What if my manager says no?

Ask what you'd need to achieve and by when to make it happen, then get a specific review date. A "no" with a clear path is very different from a dead end.

Should I tell my employer I have another offer?

Only if you genuinely have one and would accept it. Using a counteroffer as leverage when you have no intention of leaving is a short-term win with long-term trust costs.

Is it better to negotiate over email or in person?

In person or video call. Email gives your manager time to say no before you've made your case. A live conversation lets you respond to concerns in real time.

How do I find out what my role should pay?

Use Indeed Salaries, Glassdoor, and LinkedIn Salary Insights. Cross-reference at least three sources and filter by your specific location and experience level.